4th Circuit Case Commentaries

Title VII’s Religious-Employer Exemption Does Not Shield Religiously Motivated Sex Discrimination

Date: Oct 18, 2026

Title VII’s Religious-Employer Exemption Does Not Shield Religiously Motivated Sex Discrimination Commentary on John Doe v. Catholic Relief Services United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth...

Statutory Title IX Enforcement Challenges Are Not Automatically Tucker Act Contract Claims

Date: Oct 17, 2026

Statutory Title IX Enforcement Challenges Are Not Automatically Tucker Act Contract Claims Case: Arlington School Board v. Linda McMahon, consolidated with the Fairfax County School Board’s appeal,...

Title IX Enforcement Challenges Require Claim-Specific Tucker Act Analysis, Not Wholesale Dismissal

Date: Oct 17, 2026

Title IX Enforcement Challenges Require Claim-Specific Tucker Act Analysis, Not Wholesale Dismissal Case: Fairfax County School Board v. Linda McMahon, consolidated with Arlington School Board’s...

South Carolina’s Offer-or-Attempt Assault Offense Remains a Guidelines Crime of Violence After Clemons

Date: Oct 17, 2026

South Carolina’s Offer-or-Attempt Assault Offense Remains a Guidelines Crime of Violence After Clemons Case: United States v. Jesse Owens, No. 25-4469 Court: United States Court of Appeals for the...

Family-Based Asylum Nexus on Reopening Requires Consideration of New Evidence in the Context of the Entire Record

Date: Oct 16, 2026

Family-Based Asylum Nexus on Reopening Requires Consideration of New Evidence in the Context of the Entire Record Jenyfer Fajardo-Rivas v. Todd Blanche United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth...

Prison-Official Assaults: Substantial Injury Risk, Not Actual Injury, Governs the Official-Victim Enhancement

Date: Oct 16, 2026

Prison-Official Assaults: Substantial Injury Risk, Not Actual Injury, Governs the Official-Victim Enhancement Case: United States v. Nazeer Vick Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth...

Separate Sentencings Can Render a Defendant Ineligible for USSG § 4C1.1’s Zero-Point Offender Reduction, and Guideline Errors May Be Affirmed as Harmless Where the Same Sentence Would Be Imposed

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Separate Sentencings Can Render a Defendant Ineligible for USSG § 4C1.1’s Zero-Point Offender Reduction, and Guideline Errors May Be Affirmed as Harmless Where the Same Sentence Would Be Imposed 1....

Separate Sentencings Can Defeat the USSG § 4C1.1 “Zero-Point Offender” Reduction and Support Assumed-Error Harmlessness Review in Guidelines Disputes

Date: Sep 22, 2026

Separate Sentencings Can Defeat the USSG § 4C1.1 “Zero-Point Offender” Reduction and Support Assumed-Error Harmlessness Review in Guidelines Disputes 1. Introduction United States v. Robin Johnson is...

Premeditation May Be Inferred From Seconds of Reflection Between Shots When Applying the § 2K2.1(c)(1)(A) Attempted First-Degree Murder Cross-Reference

Date: Sep 18, 2026

Premeditation May Be Inferred From Seconds of Reflection Between Shots When Applying the § 2K2.1(c)(1)(A) Attempted First-Degree Murder Cross-Reference 1. Introduction United States v. Angelo Reid,...

Fourth Circuit: Long-Present, Uninspected Entrants Are Detained Under § 1226(a), Not § 1225(b)(2)(A), and Must Receive Bond Hearings

Date: Sep 15, 2026

Fourth Circuit: Long-Present, Uninspected Entrants Are Detained Under § 1226(a), Not § 1225(b)(2)(A), and Must Receive Bond Hearings I. Introduction In a published decision issued September 10, 2026,...

Fourth Circuit: Long-Present, Uninspected Entrants Are Detained Under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a) and Must Receive Bond Hearings; “Seeking Admission” Narrows § 1225(b)(2)(A)

Date: Sep 14, 2026

Fourth Circuit: Long-Present, Uninspected Entrants Are Detained Under 8 U.S.C. § 1226(a) and Must Receive Bond Hearings; “Seeking Admission” Narrows § 1225(b)(2)(A) I. Introduction In Oscar Lopez...

Fourth Circuit: Shackling During Labor/Immediate Postpartum Without Security Justification Violates the Eighth Amendment; Postpartum MOUD Denial Can Constitute Deliberate Indifference and Support ADA/RA Claims

Date: Sep 14, 2026

Fourth Circuit: Shackling During Labor/Immediate Postpartum Without Security Justification Violates the Eighth Amendment; Postpartum MOUD Denial Can Constitute Deliberate Indifference and Support...

Automatic Deletion Under Neutral Retention Policies Does Not Warrant a Criminal Spoliation Adverse-Inference Instruction Absent Prior Knowledge of Relevance and Willful Loss

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Automatic Deletion Under Neutral Retention Policies Does Not Warrant a Criminal Spoliation Adverse-Inference Instruction Absent Prior Knowledge of Relevance and Willful Loss I. Introduction In United...

Striking a Cooperating Witness’s Testimony as an Adequate Brady Cure; Conditional Intent and Two‑Step Digital Warrants Sustain VICAR Convictions

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Striking a Cooperating Witness’s Testimony as an Adeate Brady Cure; Conditional Intent and Two‑Step Digital Warrants Sustain VICAR Convictions 1. Introduction In United States v. Jairo Gustavo...

Curative Instruction by Striking a Witness’s Testimony Can Cure Mid‑Trial Brady Prejudice; Digital Warrants May Permit Broad Review Where Seizure Is Cabined to Enumerated Crimes

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Curative Instruction by Striking a Witness’s Testimony Can Cure Mid‑Trial Brady Prejudice; Digital Warrants May Permit Broad Review Where Seizure Is Cabined to Enumerated Crimes Case: United States...

Striking a Witness’s Testimony as a Sufficient Remedy for a Mid‑Trial Brady Disclosure (and Upholding Broad-Search/Narrow-Seizure Digital Warrants)

Date: Sep 12, 2026

Striking a Witness’s Testimony as a Sufficient Remedy for a Mid‑Trial Brady Disclosure (and Upholding Broad-Search/Narrow-Seizure Digital Warrants) 1. Introduction In United States v. Melvin Canales...

Fourth Circuit: Objective Recklessness Establishes Willful FBAR Liability, and Aggregate Willful FBAR Penalties Are Not “Grossly Disproportional” When Far Below the Statutory Maximum

Date: Sep 5, 2026

Fourth Circuit: Objective Recklessness Establishes Willful FBAR Liability, and Aggregate Willful FBAR Penalties Are Not “Grossly Disproportional” When Far Below the Statutory Maximum 1. Introduction...

Striking a Defendant’s Entire Closing Argument Is a Prejudicial Abuse of Discretion

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Striking a Defendant’s Entire Closing Argument Is a Prejudicial Abuse of Discretion (Even If Parts Were Improper) I. Introduction In United States v. Cristian Arevalo Arias (consolidated appeals...

Striking the Entire Defense Closing Argument Is a Prejudicial Abuse of Discretion Even When Parts Are Improper

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Striking the Entire Defense Closing Argument Is a Prejudicial Abuse of Discretion Even When Parts Are Improper I. Introduction In United States v. Cristian Ariel Arevalo Arias, United States v....

Fourth Circuit: A Trial Court Abuses Its Discretion by Striking a Defendant’s Entire Closing Argument, Thereby Effectively Denying the Constitutional Right to Summation

Date: Sep 4, 2026

Fourth Circuit: A Trial Court Abuses Its Discretion by Striking a Defendant’s Entire Closing Argument, Thereby Effectively Denying the Constitutional Right to Summation 1. Introduction United States...